本篇內容有未播出內容,不想先知道者請勿閱讀。

 作者  PAPAYASTRAY (對鴨對鴨)                              看板  SuperStarAve
 標題  [雷文] 1109晚場詳細分數雷
 時間  Sun Nov  9 23:11:04 2008

本集過關標準:16分
從失敗區選出一人淘汰
分數前三名者將由周華健擇一
在周華健12/27演唱會擔任嘉賓
有些對話是靠印象記下來的
如有遺漏或誤解請見諒
有修改一下可能會引起誤會的地方

第一次po雷文 抱歉 > <
                                                                               
                                                                               
                                                琥 胖 玲 伍 R 合計
周華健  明天我要嫁給你
                                                                               
袁惟仁  Sweet Child O' Mine / 原唱:槍與玫瑰
                                                                               
徐熙娣  至少還有你 / 原唱:林憶蓮
                                                                               
方宥心  親愛的你怎麼不在身邊 / 原唱:江美琪      2  3  3  4  4  16
                                                                               
        其實我覺得唱得很棒耶,情感很夠很投入,
        老實說根本沒發現到台語唱腔...
                                                                               
黃小琥  不只是朋友
                                                                               
洪千涵  For No Reason / 原唱:王若琳             3  4  3  4  4  18
                                                                               
        我看小玲老師的燈只有亮兩個,
        不過旁邊的朋友說第三個是亮了又暗...所以應該是這個分數...

夏政峰  陽光宅男 / 原唱:周杰倫                  2  3  4  3  4  16
                                                                               
        小胖老師多給一分救了夏政峰
        咬字還是讓人聽不懂 ( ̄ ̄;)
        小玲老師還是老話一句:"你的咬字有進步了,但是要再快一點"
                                                                               
陳樂軒  記念 / 原唱:蔡健雅                      4  4  3  4  3  18
                                                                               
        自彈自唱,Roger說會暴露缺點
        小胖老師卻很喜歡
        華健:有touching到,只是要換一把吉他
                                                                               
張涵雅  愛 / 原唱:莫文蔚                        3  4  3  3  3  16
                                                                               
        補一分過關再度出現,這次是小琥老師補的
        小琥老師:下次希望你在情緒這麼激動的情況下,還是能唱完整,
        要把你滿滿的情感唱到歌裡面去感動人
        老實說我有被感動到...
                                                                               
林鴻鳴  Kiss Goodbye / 原唱:王力宏              4  4  4  4  4  20
                                                                               
        王力宏 + 搖滾風
        除了一次音跑掉外,真的沒啥好挑剔的
                                                                               
康禎庭  癢 / 原唱:黃齡                          5  4  4  4  4  21
                                                                               
        唱到大家都癢了
        很完整的演出,假音撒嬌超強
                                                                               
許雨柔  無底洞 / 原唱:蔡健雅                    3  3  3  3  3  15
                                                                               
        低音下不去...
        進入失敗區的時候,聽到小胖老師說了句:"不會吧..."
        因為她是今天第一位失敗的
        加上前面一路順著過關下來,大家都以為今天可能是雨柔要走了
                                                                               
張心傑  對不起謝謝 / 原唱:陳奕迅                4  3  3  3  3  16
                                                                               
        周華健很喜歡他主歌前四句的自信和穩定
        何書宇偷偷跑到失敗區跟雨柔玩起來了
                                                                               
梁一貞  會呼吸的痛 / 原唱:梁靜茹                2  3  3  3  3  14
                                                                               
        聲音乾乾的、高音扁扁的、音準飄飄的
        小胖老師覺得這首歌不難,所以更應該唱出感情,但是卻平掉了
        關鍵的小琥老師覺得她不能駕馭這首歌曲
                                                                               
吳勇濱  志明與春嬌 / 原唱:五月天                2  3  3  3  4  15
                                                                               
        Roger很喜歡,可是不知為啥整首歌感覺平掉了
                                                                               
孫碧娜  祝福了 / 原唱:許茹芸                    4  3  3  3  3  16
                                                                               
        非常穩定,但是也是被評太安全,不夠感動
        關鍵的小琥老師說她有被感動到
                                                                               
吳德宏  口是心非 / 原唱:張雨生                  3  3  3  3  4  16
                                                                               
        高音不夠上去,可惜了
                                                                               
                                                                               
                                                                               
前三名:康禎庭 林鴻鳴 洪千涵/陳樂軒
                                                                               
周華健演唱會嘉賓:康禎庭 林鴻鳴
淘汰的是:梁一貞                                                         
                                                                               
關鍵人物:小琥老師...
                                                                               
關鍵字:安全,只要被提到你是"很安全地唱",就準備進入失敗區...
                                                                               
例外:有人說感覺有touching                                                 
                                                                               
淘汰共通點:有在偶像劇原聲帶發聲,個人特色都稍嫌不足  qq                  
                                                                               
題外話,小S嘴巴真的是有夠毒 XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD
                                                                               
小玲老師兩集下來應該可以建立穩定的主婦形象 (茶)

 作者  cindy0124 ()                                        看板  SuperStarAve
 標題  [雷文] 1109錄影心得
 時間  Mon Nov 10 00:35:13 2008

好累好累好累!!!!!
                                                                               
s話好多...蔡康永比較有智慧一些...
                                                                               
還是比較喜歡陶子姊的訪問啦
                                                                               
會帶到參賽者本身 感覺上是很真心誠意的聊
                                                                               
也會聊背後的一些心酸
                                                                               
我記得之前快歌不是都會聊什麼初級班中級班嗎
                                                                               
現在s都不會問...只有問一些服裝上或表演上的...
                                                                               
好吧 這個也許是個人風格
快歌的這場 其實沒有很好看
                                                                               
(唉...就是必須這麼說)
                                                                               
該有爆點的沒有 原本有肢障的也沒有因為訪問而變得有梗
                                                                               
                                                                               
評審指定曲有好一些
                                                                               
而且出現了許多耳熟能詳的歌
                                                                               
不過一貞 真的好可惜呀
                                                                               
第九夜的故事我還記得很清楚說...
                                                                               
宣布是一貞淘汰的時候 我有飆出一滴淚
                                                                               
雖然我是娜娜粉絲啦 (但娜娜也很愛一貞喔!!)
                                                                               
懷抱了這麼多夢想站上舞台 又是這麼有實力的人...
最後我不得不說...
                                                                               
以後真的不能錄短一點嗎...
                                                                               
擺在後面的選手們為了節省時間,訪問都草草結束
                                                                               
重點是 居然沒有讓大家擁抱一貞!!!  (s跟康就這麼走掉的時候 現場超多人呆滯的)
                                                                               
這2位一走掉 後面哭成一片 沒抱抱好可惜啦!!!
                                                                               
                                                                               
吼~很累的結束了
                                                                               
直覺大家會衝著s來收看節目...

 作者  chufan (愛的軌跡...)                                看板  SuperStarAve
 標題  [雷文] 11/9 晚場錄影
 時間  Sun Nov  9 18:48:14 2008

感謝碧娜團的魚幫忙連線<(_ _)>
                                                                               
主題:評審指定曲
                                                                               
過關標準:16分
                                                                               
評審:Roger、小伍、小玲、小胖、小琥 客座:周華健(不評分)
                                                                               
                                                                               
1.方宥心-親愛的你怎麼不在身邊  16分
                                                                               
2.洪千涵-For no reason         18分
                                                                               
3.夏政峰-陽光宅男              16分 (小胖本來給2分又多加1分= = 過關)
                                                                               
4.陳樂軒-記念                  18分
                                                                               
5.張涵雅-愛                    16分
                                                                               
6.林鴻鳴-Kiss Goodbye          20分
                                                                               
7.康禎庭-癢                    21分

8.許雨柔-無底洞                15分

9.張心傑-對不起謝謝            16分
                                                                               
10.梁一貞-會呼吸的痛           14分
                                                                               
11.吳勇濱-志明與春嬌           15分
                                                                               
12.孫碧娜-祝福了               16分
                                                                               
13.吳德宏-口是心非             16分
                                                                               
                                                                               
最後淘汰:梁一貞

 作者  a27281591 (皮皮)                                    看板  SuperStarAve
 標題  [雷文] 11/9 第一場 快歌
 時間  Sun Nov  9 20:06:34 2008

感謝 adalilin 大啊
                                                                               
沒記到的不要怪我  記性不好 (被毆)
                                                                               
                                                                               
主持人:
                                                                               
一開始的OPEN當然是非常棒的啦  S還是跟在康熙一樣
                                                                               
非常喜歡"爆點"  不過主持風格跟流程比較不一樣
                                                                               
沒有賽前專訪 直接上 唱完聊完 分數出來就掰掰~
                                                                               
最好笑的是 兩個都不會看分數XDDDDDDD
                                                                               
蔡康永每次都 我們來看xxx的分數是 1...1....1...........8

奇怪  難道是我們都看習慣了  不是應該很簡單  囧
                                                                               
也會去"災區"連線  小s果然不適合走悲情路線~
                                                                               
                                                                               
評審:
                                                                               
小胖:陶子說四班運氣很好  可以有兩個A咖來帶領  小S:我有偷塞5000元給他
                                                                               
小胖還說 為什麼主持人都不放過我      瘋狂被攻擊啊
                                                                               
小玲被嘲笑說是憤怒的主婦XD  今天火力大了些 (汗)
                                                                               
小伍:(小s表演完後)你的表演很溫馨  小S:溫馨! (翻白眼)
                                                                               
順便說一下 roger老師出書了 書名叫"藏絀"  (好熟悉的字眼@@)
                                                                               
                                                                               
淘汰:
                                                                               
何書宇分數(11)  就想說完了  很難留下來
                                                                               
坐在失敗區就是一直哭  他說很對不起大家的耳朵  (都不敢看那邊)
                                                                               
不過上台知道自己被淘汰後  都沒哭  超有GUTS啦!
                                                                               
                                                                               
參賽者(出場順序不太對):
                                                                               
陳樂軒-英文歌  下半身怎麼動就是動到上半身  把小s氣瘋
                                                                               
洪千涵         爆點很大  真的看的出來是拼了  但是歌聲很小
                                                                               
林鴻鳴-戰舞/王宏恩  被看出是不情願表演  也有爆點 >///< (但是有點兒童不宜)
                                                                               
許雨柔-Mi/鄭秀文   扒衣服的爆點 看的有點快噴鼻血
                                                                               
梁一貞-人來瘋/溫嵐
                                                                               
吳德宏-向前走/林強  19分 本集最高  表演恰到好處  包準好笑啦~
                                                                               
張心傑-寶貝對不起/草蜢  跟四個舞者跳的很開心  真好  有點聳的感覺XD
 
方宥心-狠狠愛/徐若瑄  因為膝蓋舊傷復發  有點綁手綁腳
                                                                               
吳勇濱-墓仔埔也敢去/伍佰  一看就知道是特地為他的層級而設計  但是很可愛
                                                                               
-------------------------失敗區--------------------------
                                                                               
康禎庭(15)-你是壞人/楊丞琳  聲音好小聲~
                                                                               
孫碧娜(15)  居然被說很假  不需要裝  而且美聲唱法還是被挑了  (怒)
                                                                               
張涵雅(15)  小玲:不知是不是再忙期中考...  小s:果然是主婦界代表
                                                                               
何書宇(11)-飛向陽光飛向你/脫拉庫  一破音落詞後面就倒光光了  且都唱一樣平
                                                                               
夏政峰(13)-我不會唱歌/周定緯  挑這種歌危險啊 咬字不好還挑字多的歌...
                                                                               
       唱不好(落詞完就打回原形 口齒不清) 跳不好(跟舞群不搭 SOLO的地板軟掉)
                                                                               
                                                                               
上面兩個   淘汰誰都沒差  何是完全不行啊  氣氛沒帶到  也不知唱什麼
                                                                               
                         夏是 評審期待很大  失望更大  反而害到他
                                                                               
補充: 小s主持  處處都是爆點  而且真的很愛唱 XDDD
                                                                               
      有再看康熙來了的感覺  還好節目是10點播~

 作者  fish0103 (在海裡的魚,想飛)                         看板  SuperStarAve
 標題  [雷文] 11/09錄影心得
 時間  Mon Nov 10 02:26:35 2008

第一場實況雷來不及聯絡上chufan大
不然應該可以兩場都幫大家轉播的
真是不好意思,對不起各位Q口Q                                                
                                                                               
(第一次PO雷文心得,還請鞭小力一點 囧)                                
                                                                               
連看了兩場,也坐了快八個多小時吧?
有被某些人的歌聲感動、也被某人的分數給氣到快瘋
全部都講怕敘述的不好,所以以下只提我印象比較深刻的表演。                  
                                                                               
快歌部分:
                                                                               
#張心傑-寶貝對不起(草蜢) 18分

心傑的舞蹈動作雖然大都很類似,
可是搭配這首歌就覺得好可愛XD
然後這首歌把我拉回小時候,好懷念啊-///-   
                                                                               
#許雨柔-Mi(鄭秀文) 18分
                                                                               
拿著教鞭讓我想起拉拉的[咕嘰咕嘰] 囧
                                                                               
中段由Dancer扯開衣服,
原本的長褲變成熱褲+網襪
   上衣變成馬甲(類似)
沒想到Dancer又扯=口=
變成金色的細肩吊帶,
(整個很像變魔術)
                                                                               
一開始總覺得她服裝怪怪的
原來大有玄機 全場驚呼啊XD
只能用喔賣尬來形容 真的!

#吳德宏-向前走(林強) 19分
                                                                               
知道分數的時候很意外
因為他在這首歌的舞蹈動作不多
而且有點搭不太起來
可是小刀唱這首歌還頗適合的 囧
                                                                               
正當對分數疑惑的時候
小胖說話了
他說張宇不久前有打電話給他
問他學長姊合唱賽的事情
說小刀明明走音了
加上pitch也不準為什麼他們還給24分balabala之類的
之後就是小胖的解釋了(請看播出(希望不會被剪掉))
(印象中,小胖好像是回張宇說現場聽跟收音有差之類的)
                                                                               
                                                                               
#夏政峰-我不會唱歌(周定緯) 13分
                                                                               
為什麼會提這組咧? 因為補燈。
                                                                               
原本每個評審都給兩分(如果沒看錯)
但劉真、小玲跟Roger後面又各補一分才變十三,
也就是說,他原本只有十分。
                                                                               
                                                                               
--------------------------------------------------------
第二場
主題:評審指定曲
                                                                               
也許是因為歌曲是針對罩門,
所以大家的表現幾乎都沒平常的好。
                                                                               
但講到這場,就不得不提一下康禎庭。
21分,全場最高分
                                                                               
她的評審指定曲是大陸歌手黃齡的〔癢〕,
康康說:『如果我唱到大家覺得很癢或是有一點點癢,那我就成功了』
她真的成功了,唱到我真的有癢 囧
                                                                               
                                                                               
然後...特別提一下夏先生這組,
實在是看不下去很久、也看不下去了。
#夏政峰-陽光宅男(周杰倫) 16分
                                                                               
      琥  胖  玲 伍 R
(評審給分:2、”3”、4、3、4)
                                                                               
原本小胖只給兩分,小玲跟小胖交頭接耳後,
小胖就又多按了一分。
S問說是誰加的分時(兩人這時好像還有在講話),
小玲還讓(叫)小胖解釋原因。
                                                                               
師太劈頭就直接說:『不會唱歌,光靠舞台魅力能撐多久?』
還是師太比較威Q_________Q
                                                                               
                                                                               
--------------------------------------------------------
第二場失敗區共三人(許雨柔、梁一貞、吳勇濱)
最後淘汰:梁一貞。
                                                                               
後來到大樓外面等參賽者,
雨柔一直很擔心自己會被網友罵(因為淘汰的是一貞)
                                                                               
很想跟雨柔說,
我覺得第二場在失敗區的三個,都沒有人應該被淘汰。
該淘汰的人是安然無恙坐在座位上的那個。
                                                                               
以上,是私心很大的錄影心得。
感謝各位不怕傷眼的看完,
最後附上第一場詳細歌單+分數。
                                                                               
--------------------------------------------------------
評審:劉真、小胖、小玲、小伍、Roger
(以下分數排列按照上述評審排列)
                                                                               
                                                                               
1.陳樂軒-Mambo No.5(Lou Bega) 17分
(評審給分:3、3、3、4、4)
                                                                               
                                                                               
2.何書宇-飛向陽光飛向你(拖拉庫) 11分
(評審給分:2、2、2、2、3)
                                                                               
                                                                               
3.洪千涵-單身女子俱樂部(本多RuRu) 17分
(評審給分:3、3、3、4、4)

4.康禎庭-你是壞人(揚丞琳) 15分
(評審給分:3、3、3、3、3)
                                                                               
                                                                               
5.梁一貞-人來瘋(溫嵐) 16分
(評審給分:3、3、3、3、4)
                                                                               
                                                                               
6.張心傑-寶貝對不起(草蜢) 18分
(評審給分:4、4、3、3、4)
                                                                               
                                                                               
7.林鴻鳴-戰舞(王宏恩) 16分
(評審給芬:3、3、3、3、4)
                                                                               
                                                                               
8.許雨柔-Mi(鄭秀文) 18分
(評審給分:4、4、4、3、3)

9.方宥心-狠狠愛(徐若瑄) 17分
(評審給分:4、3、3、3、4)
                                                                               
                                                                               
10.吳勇濱-墓仔埔也敢去(伍佰) 18分
(評審給分:3、3、4、4、4)
                                                                               
                                                                               
11.吳德宏-向前走(林強) 19分
(評審給分:3、4、4、4、4)
                                                                               
                                                                               
12.張涵雅-Sunny day(李玟) 15分
(評審給分:3、3、3、3、3)
                                                                               
                                                                               
13.夏政峰-我不會唱歌(周定緯) 13分
(評審給分:3、2、3、2、3)
                                                                               
                                                                               
14.孫碧娜-日出(張惠妹) 15分
(評審給分:3、3、3、3、3)

 作者  jokehank (A  Da)                                    看板  SuperStarAve
 標題  [雷文] 11/09錄影心得
 時間  Mon Nov 10 03:19:19 2008

第一次PO心得
                                                                               
私心很大的心得
                                                                               
複製樓上fish0103 (在海裡的魚,想飛) 大大的文章                            
                                                                               
#夏政峰-我不會唱歌(周定緯) 13分
                                                                               
為什麼會提這組咧? 因為補燈。
                                                                               
原本每個評審都給兩分(如果沒看錯)
但劉真、小玲跟Roger後面又各補一分才變十三,
也就是說,他原本只有十分。

然後...特別提一下夏先生這組,
實在是看不下去很久、也看不下去了。
                                                                               
#夏政峰-陽光宅男(周杰倫) 16分
                                                                               
      琥  胖  玲 伍 R
(評審給分:2、”3”、4、3、4)
                                                                               
原本小胖只給兩分,小玲跟小胖交頭接耳後,
小胖就又多按了一分。
S問說是誰加的分時(兩人這時好像還有在講話),
小玲還讓(叫)小胖解釋原因。
                                                                               
師太劈頭就直接說:『不會唱歌,光靠舞台魅力能撐多久?』
還是師太比較威Q_________Q
以上真的有這件事情,我也有去錄影
                                                                               
也是親眼看到,覺得超級誇張!
                                                                               
我個人不討厭夏先生,
                                                                               
也覺得他很可愛
                                                                               
甚至有那麼一兩首歌,我覺得他唱的還蠻不錯的,真的有進步!                     
                                                                               
可是今天這兩首歌,真的是NOT GOOD!!!!                                       
                                                                               
而且黃太太也很瞎,每次都用這幾句話來壓觀眾!
                                                                               
咬字有進步
  咬字有進步
    咬字有進步
      咬字有進步
        咬字有進步
        真的有成長
      真的有成長
    真的有成長
  真的有成長
真的有成長
舞台魅力分數很高
舞台魅力分數很高
舞台魅力分數很高
舞台魅力分數很高
舞台魅力分數很高
舞台魅力分數很高
很有明星特質
很有明星特質
很有明星特質
很有明星特質
很有明星特質
                                                                               
真的每一次都有進步嘛!?今天唱的兩首,真的不知道他在唱什麼

之前有很幾次,黃太太都這樣幫他加分,等到大家都給完分數後,再補分
                                                                               
我個人覺得黃太太這樣很不中肯!                                                 
                                                                               
而且我真的覺得這明明就是歌唱比賽呀,評分的標準很不清楚
                                                                               
到底是評當場唱個感覺好不好,還是這個人有沒有進步
                                                                               
假如以梁小姐來講,她一開始實力就蠻強的,以10分來講
                                                                               
梁小姐一開始的實力有6分,現在這場演唱她唱到7分的實力
                                                                               
夏先生一開始實力2分來講,他進步了,當場他唱到5分的實力
                                                                               
那到底是要給梁小姐唱出7分實力高分,還是夏先生唱到5分實力進步3分高分

好幾場都讓我覺得評審都給進步分                                             
                                                                               
評審我還是喜歡這個組合
陳子鴻、黃小琥、張宇、伍思凱、ROGER                                        
                                                                               
之前夏先生分數莫名的很高,那時候都覺得沒差,
因為當天淘汰的人都是真的也是唱不好的人,落差不會太大                         
                                                                               
不過今天我覺得梁小姐,還沒有到唱到該被淘汰的地步
她是被犧牲的吧,好可憐!我想梁小姐應該比較有料!!!                         
                                                                               
錄完兩場,真的很悶!
P.S
1、以上是個人心得,如有違規,麻煩告訴我一下!
2、完完全全的討厭黃太太!
3、小琥老師真的很威!(歡迎你常來)
4、張宇趕快回來!
5、期許星光有真實質感,不是大愛的精神!



arrow
arrow
    全站熱搜

    osakicom 發表在 痞客邦 留言(0) 人氣()